W2LIE.net: Why buff anywhere else?

Submit your quote!
http://www.w2lie.net/sales
Sponsored By:
http://www.breakingnewsnetwork.com     http://www.scannermaster.com/?Click=6262
  http://www.monitorlongisland.com/advertise

Main Menu
Monthly Donations

Please help support this site
Donations will be used to cover monthly web space
Thank You !!


Premium Membership
You are not a Premium Member

Why not sign up today and take advantage of premium benefits?
Benefits include:
  • shopping discounts
  • Web Controlled Radio
  • Immediate Access to Archived Audio
  • Ad Free Browsing

Please Click here for more info

Welcome Guest
Username:

Password:


Remember me

[ ]
[ ]
[ ]
 Currently Online (20)
There are 12051 members
Newest member: Fah_cough

 Last Visitors
 Members on Today: 4


 



Forums
W2LIE.net | Monitor Long Island, Inc. :: Forums :: Radios and Hardware :: Antennas and Reception
Moderators: w2lie, Chieftaz, BobLandau, quint14, LI_Scan_Guy, cwerner, DecodeUp
Go to page       >>  

ST-2 v. Radioshack Discone or other?

<< Previous thread | Next thread >>



Print View Posted: Sun Oct 04 2009, 11:53pm
Posted by: shkesslerPosts: 246
User Buff Group ID
Old Display Name: EASTROCKS400
Joined: Thu Jul 24 2008, 05:17pm

Looking for a base antenna to throw up in the attic

Would love to have great reception on UHF as most depts/police agencies around here are on that band.

Any suggestions? Phil recommend the ST-2 but i will not be mounting it high up.

THANKS.




Back to top AOL IM

Posted: Mon Oct 05 2009, 01:07am

Posted by: w2liePosts: 2830

User Buff Group ID
Old Display Name: w2lie
Location: Long Island, NY
Your Admin
Premium Member Premium Member
Joined: Fri Nov 04 2005, 03:28am

I have a discone antenna in my attic. It doesn't work as well as an outdoor antenna, but it gets the job done.

Discone is sitting on the floor in the corner, so it is out of the way.

For an indoor antenna, I would suggest this over the ST-2 since the ST-2 may not fit in your attic.
Back to top Website MSN IM User Gallery Myspace Facebook YouTube Album
Posted: Mon Oct 05 2009, 12:43pm
Posted by: ipfd320Posts: 1864
User Buff Group ID
Location: Martin County Florida
Account terminated as requested
Joined: Sat Mar 31 2007, 02:05am

how about utilizing the old t.v antenna on your roof....as listed in older post ive been using mine and works fine
Back to top
Posted: Tue Oct 06 2009, 12:08am
Posted by: shkesslerPosts: 246
User Buff Group ID
Old Display Name: EASTROCKS400
Joined: Thu Jul 24 2008, 05:17pm

Sadly i do not have an older TV antenna on the roof. I mean i think it's kind of ridiculous to spend 70$ on RS while the ST-2 costs 50$ with tons of coax
Back to top AOL IM
Posted: Sun Oct 11 2009, 06:50am
Posted by: LukePosts: 305
Old Display Name: Luke
Donating Member
Joined: Tue Mar 14 2006, 04:53pm

If your talking about the ST-2 Scantenna, it's likely it won't fit in your attic unless you have a tall attic. On the contrary, you can always lay it on its side.

I'm a fan of the scantenna. I have one and it works well. Mine is also outside so I'm not sure how reception will be affected with it placed inside.

I'd definitely be interested in hearing what you went with and your observations.
Back to top
Posted: Sun Oct 11 2009, 11:27am
Posted by: shkesslerPosts: 246
User Buff Group ID
Old Display Name: EASTROCKS400
Joined: Thu Jul 24 2008, 05:17pm

Well after researching, the scantenna will not fit in my attic.

I am down to the ST4 or maybe the Diamond D130. anyone?
Back to top AOL IM
Posted: Sun Oct 11 2009, 03:49pm
Posted by: ipfd320Posts: 1864
User Buff Group ID
Location: Martin County Florida
Account terminated as requested
Joined: Sat Mar 31 2007, 02:05am

this is getting confusing....lol
Back to top
Posted: Sun Oct 11 2009, 08:21pm
Posted by: shkesslerPosts: 246
User Buff Group ID
Old Display Name: EASTROCKS400
Joined: Thu Jul 24 2008, 05:17pm

ALRIGHT thread closed lol.

Ill try something and then give you advice later on.
Back to top AOL IM
Posted: Mon Oct 12 2009, 08:55pm
Posted by: LukePosts: 305
Old Display Name: Luke
Donating Member
Joined: Tue Mar 14 2006, 04:53pm

6 of one, half dozen of the other if you ask me. They are both the same type of antenna and the results shouldn't vary that much between the two. These are multiband antennas. If you are looking to focus more on UHF, you should get a UHF dedicated antenna and radio.

I picked up a couple of Kenwood UHF (TK-880) radios for real cheap on E-bay and they work great! Very easy to program (with the program and cable) and they also scan all channels unlike motorola radios that scan only 16.

Now if you are looking to listen to everything, than go for a multi band. Since you only specified one band, I would get a dedicated band radio with a dedicated band antenna for best results. My UHF is hooked into a discone and it still works better than my scanners. That is also b/c its tuned for UHF. I have a UHF antenna but no place to put it.
Back to top
Posted: Mon Oct 12 2009, 09:20pm
Posted by: shkesslerPosts: 246
User Buff Group ID
Old Display Name: EASTROCKS400
Joined: Thu Jul 24 2008, 05:17pm

Uh. i am referring to an antenna for my scanner.
Back to top AOL IM
W2LIE.net Scanner Programming
Go to page       >>   

Jump:     Back to top

Syndicate this thread: rss 0.92 Syndicate this thread: rss 2.0 Syndicate this thread: RDF
Powered by e107 Forum System






Link to w2lie.net
Click the sample image below for Link Codes




Advertisers

http://www.w2lie.net/apps/content/content.php?content.26

 

 

 

 

 

 

http://www.monitorlongisland.com/advertise

http://www.monitorlongisland.com/advertise

http://www.monitorlongisland.com/advertise

All original content is copyright 2005-2019, Monitor Long Island, Inc. All rights reserved.
The original content herein may not be used with out the express written consent of Monitor Long Island, Inc.

Live feeds may not be abused in any manner. Please read the Live Feed Terms of Service: [link]
e107 Disclaimer can be found here: [link]